Current:Home > StocksPredictIQ-The Surprising History of Climate Change Coverage in College Textbooks -AssetTrainer
PredictIQ-The Surprising History of Climate Change Coverage in College Textbooks
Benjamin Ashford View
Date:2025-04-09 16:57:34
If you were an American college student studying biology in the 1970s,PredictIQ your course textbook probably contained information about standard topics like photosynthesis, cellular division, genetics and food chains. But you might also have come across something less expected, tucked in the last few pages of your book: an explanation of the greenhouse effect and what it could mean for global temperatures in the future.
“I was really, really surprised that it had been in our textbooks for that long,” said Jennifer Landin, an associate professor of biological sciences at North Carolina State University whose accidental discovery of a passage about global warming in a 1978 textbook sparked the idea to conduct a study of climate change coverage in undergraduate course materials. In the study, published in December, Landin and her co-author, Rabiya Arif Ansari, sought to understand how climate change was taught in college classrooms by analyzing 57 textbooks from the past 50 years.
They found that textbooks’ coverage of climate change expanded from 1970 to 2019, but that the increase was inconsistent and that the books had failed to keep pace with the volume of new scientific research on the topic, especially in the last 20 years. More surprisingly, in the 2010s, textbooks contained fewer sentences about climate change than they had in the 2000s. Landin and Ansari also found a decrease in content addressing solutions to climate change, after a peak in the 1990s, and a trend of moving climate information further and further back in the book.
One reason it matters what kind of climate information can be found in our textbooks, Landin said, is their audience, which includes the next generation of scientists, health-care workers, science teachers and researchers. “It’s important to consider that the behaviors that they form or reinforce at this stage in their lives will be hugely impactful,” she said. What young adults learn in school affects how they will view their roles in climate mitigation and adaptation, not just as students but for the rest of their professional and personal lives.
For educators, textbooks sometimes serve as a “guide to what is expected to be taught,” and they can act as a counterbalance to the varying beliefs of individual teachers. The study notes that significant numbers of teachers approach climate change as a controversial issue that needs to be presented from “both sides,” and that some of them are still teaching students that global warming has natural causes, not human ones. My own education reflected this disparity. I had an exceptional middle school science teacher who taught us about the greenhouse effect in an engaging and thoughtful way, but in high school, one of my science teachers insinuated in class that global warming was caused by natural processes and not by burning fossil fuels, which sowed confusion among his students. In my biology course, the topic was not covered at all.
If textbooks contain little information about climate change and the teacher doesn’t supplement that content with other lessons, it sends a signal to students that it’s not an urgent issue. “If there’s minimal content, we’re implicitly telling people that this topic is worth a few pages way at the end of the book,” Landin said. “And that implies that it’s not important.” Textbooks offer a window into the priorities of the time and place in which they were published. To continue to produce textbooks that treat climate change as a tangential topic telegraphs a failure to grasp how much climate change will alter our future–and has already gravely altered our present.
In the 1970s and ‘80s, the space that biology textbooks devoted to climate change–and the authors’ certainty about how greenhouse gases would ultimately affect global temperatures–varied, but the topic wasn’t uncommon. (The greenhouse effect has been known since the 19th century, an understanding that was solidified with further research in the 1950s and ‘60s.) Just like the textbooks of the 21st century, the books in use a generation ago give us a glimpse into the thinking of a particular time, one that turns out to be not so different from our own.
One example appears in a 1982 textbook, “Elements of Biology,” which suggests that increasing levels of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere “could dramatically cause the world’s temperature to rise.”
“It has been estimated that a rise of 2°C in the annual mean temperature would not only produce significant climatologic changes but would cause the glacial ice caps to melt,” the book explains, which would lead to catastrophic sea level rise and threaten to “submerge many of the world’s major cities.”
Even textbooks from this era that don’t explicitly address global warming still warn of a looming “ecological crisis” triggered by pollution, deforestation, dwindling resources and an exploding human population. “Life on Earth,” from 1978, concludes with a bleak prediction:
“We believe that mankind is about to enter one of the Dark Ages of human history. Most of the ecological problems that threaten us will be resolved by the end of the 21st century, either by human intelligence or by nature’s ruthless indifference.”
“Biology: The World of Life,” also from 1978, strikes a similar tone in a section that feels both prescient and eerily familiar. “Will it be said by the survivors of our era that we stupidly and insensitively foreclosed their future and demeaned their existence? Will our children curse us?” the book asks. Unlike “Life on Earth,” “The World of Life” leaves the door of possibility open, if only a sliver: “Or will they gratefully stand in admiration of our strength, dignity and wisdom at a time when decisions are hard?” The book is frank with its readers, telling them that the answers to these questions “depends on what you do, what you will allow and what you simply will not allow.”
What will the science textbooks of tomorrow have to say about today, about what we allowed and what we did not? “The World of Life” was published 44 years ago, a message in an academic bottle from the past. But its questions linger in our own “time when decisions are hard,” a reminder to take seriously our obligation to the future before it’s too late.
veryGood! (855)
Related
- NHL in ASL returns, delivering American Sign Language analysis for Deaf community at Winter Classic
- Teyana Taylor Debuts Blonde Bombshell Transformation at 2024 Met Gala
- Jodie Turner-Smith Turns Heads With Striking Blonde Hair at 2024 Met Gala
- Hyundai, Ford among 257,000 vehicles recalled: Check car recalls here
- Federal hiring is about to get the Trump treatment
- A doctor whose views on COVID-19 vaccinations drew complaints has her medical license reinstated
- Dua Lipa's Confusing 2024 Met Gala Look Will Leave Your Head Spinning
- Dua Lipa's Confusing 2024 Met Gala Look Will Leave Your Head Spinning
- Senate begins final push to expand Social Security benefits for millions of people
- Kelsea Ballerini and Chase Stokes' Daring 2024 Met Gala Looks Are Proof Opposites Attract
Ranking
- Meet the volunteers risking their lives to deliver Christmas gifts to children in Haiti
- Powerful storms bring tornadoes to Oklahoma, large hail to Kansas. Forecasts warn more is to come
- Woman in Minnesota accused in the deaths of 2 children
- Shortstop CJ Abrams growing into star for Nationals: 'We’re going to go as far as he goes'
- Have Dry, Sensitive Skin? You Need To Add These Gentle Skincare Products to Your Routine
- Why Ed’s Sheeran 2024 Met Gala Look Is Reminding Fans of Zac Efron
- Horoscopes Today, May 6, 2024
- Tornado tears through northeast Oklahoma, leaves trail of damage
Recommendation
Working Well: When holidays present rude customers, taking breaks and the high road preserve peace
Pamela Anderson stepped out in makeup at the Met Gala. Here's why it's a big deal.
Tom Holland Proves He’s The Most Supportive Boyfriend After Zendaya’s 2024 Met Gala Triple Serve
Australian boy killed by police was in deradicalization program since causing school explosion
Intel's stock did something it hasn't done since 2022
See Ed Sheeran and Wife Cherry Seaborn’s Rare PDA Moment at the 2024 Met Gala
PGA Championship invites 7 LIV players to get top 100 in the world
Boeing's Starliner mission was scrubbed Monday. Here's when it will try to launch again.